Connect with us

Foodie News

The Great Turkey Debate: Butterball vs Jennie-O, and the Cook Who Makes It Matter

A personal look at the Butterball vs Jennie-O turkey debate, reflecting on family traditions, taste, and the idea that the cook—not the brand—makes the holiday meal special.

Published

on

Last Updated on November 26, 2025 by Daily News Staff

Roasted turkey representing the Butterball vs Jennie-O debate.

Roasted turkey with stuffing served on holiday table

The Great Turkey Debate: Butterball vs Jennie-O, and the Cook Who Makes It Matter

If you ask ten families which turkey brand is best, you’ll probably get ten different answers. Turkey loyalties run deep—almost as deep as the traditions we build around our holiday tables. So when someone recently asked me which is better, Jennie-O or Butterball, it made me think back to my own family’s experiences and the memories tied to those meals.

Growing up, my mother preferred Butterball. That was her go-to bird every Thanksgiving and Christmas. She trusted the brand, trusted the consistency, and trusted that no matter what else went wrong in the kitchen—and something always did—the Butterball turkey would come out juicy and reliable. She wasn’t a chef, but she cooked like someone who knew exactly what made a dish comforting: familiarity, patience, and a lot of heart.

But here’s the thing—my mom wasn’t a “Butterball or nothing” person. We had plenty of years where she used Jennie-O or whatever brand was the most accessible or affordable at the time. And you know what? The meal was still delicious. Not because of the label on the turkey, but because of who prepared it.

That’s the part people often forget:

The taste of a turkey depends just as much on the cook as on the brand.

Butterball vs. Jennie-O: What I’ve Learned

After many holiday dinners and a few turkeys I attempted on my own, here’s what I can say from experience:

🦃 Butterball

Usually comes pre-brined, which made things easier for my mom. Juicy and flavorful even if you’re not a professional cook. Great choice when you don’t want to worry about perfect seasoning.

🦃 Jennie-O

A bit milder in flavor, which is perfect if you enjoy seasoning your own bird. Leaner in many cases, especially their turkey products. Great for cooks who enjoy experimenting or customizing their flavors.

I’ve had memorable meals with both brands, but the memories weren’t shaped by the turkey itself—they were shaped by the moment. It wasn’t about whether the turkey was Jennie-O or Butterball. It was about family sitting together, laughing, arguing, telling stories, and passing dishes around the table like they were rare treasure.

And in those moments, the turkey—no matter the brand—always tasted amazing.

Advertisement
Get More From A Face Cleanser And Spa-like Massage

It’s the Cook, Not Just the Brand

Over the years I’ve learned that you can hand the exact same turkey to two different cooks—a seasoned pro and a nervous first-timer—and end up with two completely different results.

Why?

Because cooking a holiday meal isn’t just a recipe.

It’s technique, patience, and yes—love.

Experienced cooks know exactly when to baste, when to tent the foil, and when to leave the oven alone. Novices bring curiosity and determination that often leads to surprisingly great results. And family recipes passed down (or improvised on the fly) add flavors no brand can package.

In our home, the cook determined the meal, and my mother always managed to turn whatever turkey she had—Butterball, Jennie-O, or anything in between—into something special. Our immediate family always enjoyed a delicious holiday dinner, not because of the brand, but because of her hands and her heart.

So Which Is Better?

Honestly? Whichever one you cook best.

Butterball might give you a little extra cushion with moisture.

Jennie-O might give you more freedom with flavor.

But the magic doesn’t come from the wrapper—it comes from the person preparing the meal.

Advertisement
Get More From A Face Cleanser And Spa-like Massage

If you’re cooking the turkey this year, don’t stress about the brand.

Focus on the experience. Enjoy the process. Season it the way you like.

Because long after the leftovers are gone, it’s the memories around the table that stay with us.

Footnote

Growing up, my parents sometimes switched up our holiday dinners because Thanksgiving and Christmas were so close together. Instead of another large turkey, my mom began serving individual Cornish gaming hens for Thanksgiving—two small birds for each of us. Christmas stayed turkey, but the change helped cut down on the mountain of leftovers that came with cooking two big birds only weeks apart. I didn’t mind at all; I absolutely loved Cornish hens. My mom prepared them just like she did her holiday turkey, complete with stuffing and all the traditional sides. It tasted every bit as special, and those meals became some of my favorite holiday memories.

Stay Connected With STM Daily News

Looking for more stories that blend personal experience, community insight, and everyday perspectives?
Subscribe to STM Daily News for updates on food, lifestyle, local events, and the moments that bring us together around the table.

👉 Join our newsletter for weekly highlights
👉 Follow us on social media for fresh stories and behind-the-scenes coverage Instagram | TikTok | YouTube: @STMDailyNews

👉 Share your own holiday traditions in the comments and be part of the conversation

Your stories matter. Your voice matters.
Stay informed, stay inspired — only on STM Daily News.

HUNGRY FOR MORE?

Discover a feast for your senses with our Food & Drink Blog, a tantalizing part of STM Daily News. Get the latest articles, recipes, and foodie news delivered straight to your inbox. Satisfaction guaranteed!

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE THE LATEST RECIPES & FOODIE NEWS, PLUS SOME EXCLUSIVE GOODIES!

Advertisement
Get More From A Face Cleanser And Spa-like Massage

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Food and Drink

Discover more from Daily News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Rod: A creative force, blending words, images, and flavors. Blogger, writer, filmmaker, and photographer. Cooking enthusiast with a sci-fi vision. Passionate about his upcoming series and dedicated to TNC Network. Partnered with Rebecca Washington for a shared journey of love and art.

Continue Reading
Advertisement Sports Research
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Food and Beverage

Straw Hat Pizza: The Rise, Fall, and Nostalgic Legacy of a California Pizza Icon

Straw Hat Pizza was once a California pizza powerhouse. Explore the rise, decline, and nostalgic legacy of this beloved family pizza chain.

Published

on

pizza on brown wooden tray
Photo by Dario Garcia on Pexels.com

Long before pizza delivery apps, stuffed-crust gimmicks, and national chains on every corner, there was Straw Hat Pizza — a family-friendly, California-born pizza chain that helped define what “going out for pizza” meant for generations.

For many Californians, Straw Hat Pizza wasn’t just dinner. It was birthday parties, Little League celebrations, arcade games, salad bars, and the hum of a busy dining room packed with families. While the brand is far smaller today, its place in American food history is secure.

Humble Beginnings: A California Pizza Story

Straw Hat Pizza was founded in 1959 by Charlie Olson and Bill Henderlong. The first location opened in San Leandro, California, during a period when pizza was still becoming a mainstream American favorite.

The name came from the straw hats worn by pizza makers at early California pizzerias — a visual shortcut that told customers exactly what kind of place they were entering. Casual. Friendly. Pizza-focused.

Straw Hat Pizza 1977 TV commercial –
robatsea2009 Channel

The Golden Years: 1960s Through the Early 1980s

Through the 1960s and 1970s, Straw Hat Pizza expanded rapidly across California and Nevada. By 1980, the chain reportedly operated more than 200 locations, becoming a staple in suburban shopping centers and family neighborhoods.

  • Large dining rooms built for families and groups
  • Arcade games and coin-operated attractions
  • Salad bars — a defining feature of the era
  • Party rooms for birthdays and team celebrations

The pizza leaned toward what we now call California-style: thin, layered crusts, generous toppings, and a menu designed for sharing. It was food meant to be eaten at a table, not rushed out the door.

Corporate Consolidation and Decline

In 1969, Straw Hat Pizza was sold to Saga Corporation, which later became part of Marriott Corporation. As restaurant consolidation accelerated in the 1980s, Straw Hat became caught in a wave of mergers and acquisitions.

By the late 1980s, many Straw Hat locations were sold to or converted by Pizza Hut. Franchise owners fought back, eventually retaining rights to the Straw Hat name and continuing operations independently — but the brand’s footprint was permanently reduced.

How Straw Hat Pizza Survived

Unlike many mid-century restaurant chains, Straw Hat Pizza never fully disappeared. Independent franchise owners reorganized, preserving the brand, recipes, and name. Today, a limited number of Straw Hat Pizza locations continue operating — primarily in California.

It is no longer a national competitor, but rather a regional legacy brand, sustained by nostalgia and loyal local customers.

Why Straw Hat Pizza Still Matters

Straw Hat Pizza represents an era when pizza parlors were community spaces — places to linger, celebrate, and connect. Its story mirrors the rise of suburban America and the transformation of pizza from novelty to cultural staple.

For many, the memory of Straw Hat Pizza is inseparable from childhood — the smell of baked dough, the sound of arcade machines, and the excitement of a shared pie arriving at the table.

Advertisement
Get More From A Face Cleanser And Spa-like Massage

The Nostalgia Revival

Vintage menus, matchbooks, and advertisements from Straw Hat Pizza frequently surface online, part of a broader resurgence of interest in retro restaurants. These artifacts remind us that regional chains once played a major role in shaping American food culture.

Straw Hat Pizza may no longer dominate California strip malls, but its legacy lives on — in memories, collectibles, and the handful of locations still serving slices under that iconic name.

Related Coverage on STM Daily News

External References & Further Reading

STM Daily News continues to explore the food history that shaped our communities — from vanished chains to local favorites that still define how we eat and gather.

Author

  • Rod Washington

    Rod: A creative force, blending words, images, and flavors. Blogger, writer, filmmaker, and photographer. Cooking enthusiast with a sci-fi vision. Passionate about his upcoming series and dedicated to TNC Network. Partnered with Rebecca Washington for a shared journey of love and art. View all posts


Discover more from Daily News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Continue Reading

Food and Beverage

A Convenient Homecooked Solution Without the Slow Cooker

For a quick and easy version of the comfort food classic, consider this Quick Homecooked Chili that’s made in a skillet and ready in half an hour. Just brown ground beef with a chopped onion, stir in beans, tomato sauce, cubed sweet potato and a few simple seasonings and you’re well on your way to a winter warmup.

Published

on

For a quick and easy version of the comfort food classic, consider this Quick Homecooked Chili that’s made in a skillet and ready in half an hour.

Homecooked Chili

(Family Features) Walking in the door to the smell of homemade chili is sure to warm you up from the inside-out, but if you forgot to set up the slow cooker before heading out the door in the morning, don’t fret – a hearty bowl of beans, beef and stewed goodness can still await.

For a quick and easy version of the comfort food classic, consider this Quick Homecooked Chili that’s made in a skillet and ready in half an hour. Just brown ground beef with a chopped onion, stir in beans, tomato sauce, cubed sweet potato and a few simple seasonings and you’re well on your way to a winter warmup.

Find more easy ways to feed your family by visiting Culinary.net.

17782 HomecookedChili detail embed

Quick Homecooked Chili

Recipe adapted from Allrecipes

Prep time: 10 minutes

Cook time: 20 minutes

Servings: 6

  • 1          pound ground beef
  • 1          onion, chopped
  • 1          can (15 ounces) tomato sauce
  • 1          can (15 ounces) kidney beans
  • 1          can (14 1/2 ounces) stewed tomatoes
  • 1          can (10 ounces) diced tomatoes with green chilies
  • 1          sweet potato, cubed
  •             water (optional)
  • 1          teaspoon chili powder
  • 1          pinch garlic powder
  • salt, to taste
  • pepper, to taste
  • sour cream (optional)
  • sliced avocado (optional)
  1. In large saucepan over medium heat, cook ground beef and onion until meat is browned and onion is tender, 5-7 minutes.
  2. Stir in tomato sauce, kidney beans, stewed tomatoes with juices, diced tomatoes with green chilies and cubed sweet potato. Add water to reach desired consistency.
  3. Season with chili powder and garlic powder. Add salt and pepper, to taste.
  4. Bring to boil then reduce heat to low. Cover and simmer 15 minutes.
  5. Serve with sour cream and sliced avocado, if desired.

Photo courtesy of Unsplash

collect?v=1&tid=UA 482330 7&cid=1955551e 1975 5e52 0cdb 8516071094cd&sc=start&t=pageview&dl=http%3A%2F%2Ftrack.familyfeatures
SOURCE:

Culinary.net


Discover more from Daily News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Continue Reading

Recipe of the Week

Simple, Satisfying Meals for the New Year

Meals for the New Year: While you’re easing your family back into routines in the new year, simple, wholesome meals can help you stretch your grocery dollars further and find your rhythm in the kitchen again. This Sweet Potato Breakfast Bowl satisfies both eyes and stomachs through a combination of black beans, eggs and sauteed vegetables.

Published

on

Last Updated on January 25, 2026 by Daily News Staff

17760 detail intro

Simple, Satisfying Meals for the New Year

(Family Features) While you’re easing your family back into routines in the new year, simple, wholesome meals can help you stretch your grocery dollars further and find your rhythm in the kitchen again. Satisfying and approachable recipes that come together quickly using a dependable base ingredient like beans are resonating with home cooks, helping take the pressure out of cooking. Grown, cooked and canned in America, Bush’s Recipe Beans add plant-based protein and fiber to any dish, making it easy to achieve new year’s goals while bringing flavorful meals with high-quality ingredients to the table. For a warm, colorful way to start your morning without spending extra time in the kitchen, consider this Sweet Potato Breakfast Bowl, which satisfies both eyes and stomachs through a combination of black beans, eggs and sauteed vegetables. Or put a Mediterranean twist on lunch and dinner with this Greek Dense Bean Salad, a bright, fresh dish that includes chick peas and cannellini beans. Visit bushbeans.com for more meal ideas that help you cook more, spend less and gather with loved ones. Meals for the New Year: While you’re easing your family back into routines in the new year, simple, wholesome meals can help you stretch your grocery dollars further and find your rhythm in the kitchen again. This Sweet Potato Breakfast Bowl satisfies both eyes and stomachs through a combination of black beans, eggs and sauteed vegetables.

Sweet Potato Breakfast Bowl

Prep time: 5 minutes Cook time: 10 minutes Servings: 2
  • 2          tablespoons olive oil
  • 1          small yellow onion, finely chopped
  • 1          small red bell pepper, finely chopped
  • salt, to taste
  • pepper, to taste
  • 2          cups cooked sweet potatoes
  • 1          can (15 ounces) Bush’s Black Beans, drained
  • 1          teaspoon chili powder
  • 2          fried eggs
  • 1          avocado, sliced
  • cotija cheese, crumbled
  • lime wedges, for serving
  1. In large skillet over medium heat, heat olive oil. Add onions and bell pepper; cook, stirring occasionally, until peppers are softened, 5-7 minutes. Season with salt and pepper, to taste.
  2. Add sweet potatoes, black beans and chili powder; stir to combine. Cook until potatoes and beans are warmed through, 4-5 minutes.
  3. Divide bean mixture between two bowls. Top each bowl with fried egg, avocado slices and crumbled cotija cheese. Serve with lime wedges.
17760 detail embed2

Greek Dense Bean Salad

Prep time: 15 minutes Servings: 6-8 Dressing:
  • 1/4       cup extra-virgin olive oil
  • 2          tablespoons red wine vinegar
  • 1          tablespoon lemon juice
  • 1          teaspoon Dijon mustard
  • 1          garlic clove, minced
  • 1          teaspoon dried oregano
  • salt, to taste
  • pepper, to taste
Tzatziki Sauce:
  • 1/2       cup plain yogurt
  • 1/4       cucumber, grated, excess water drained
  • 2          teaspoons lemon juice
  • 2          teaspoons extra-virgin olive oil
  • 1/2       teaspoon garlic, minced
  • 2          teaspoons fresh dill, chopped
  • salt, to taste
  • pepper, to taste
Salad:
  • 1          can (16 ounces) Bush’s Chick Peas, drained and rinsed
  • 1          can (15 1/2 ounces) Bush’s Cannellini Beans, drained and rinsed
  • 1          cup cherry tomatoes, halved
  • 1/2       cup red onion, diced
  • 1          cucumber, seeded and diced
  • 1/2       cup Kalamata olives, pitted and halved
  • 1/2       cup feta cheese, crumbled
  • 1/4       cup fresh parsley, chopped
  •             Greek dressing (directions below)
  • 1          cup tzatziki sauce (directions below)
  • chicken skewers (optional), for serving
  1. To make dressing: In food processor or blender, blend olive oil; red wine vinegar; lemon juice; Dijon mustard; garlic; oregano; and salt and pepper, to taste, until well combined. Set aside.
  2. To make tzatziki sauce: In bowl, stir yogurt; cucumber; lemon juice; olive oil; garlic; dill; and salt and pepper, to taste, until well combined. Set aside.
  3. To make salad: In large bowl, combine chick peas, cannellini beans, cherry tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, olives, feta cheese and parsley; toss with dressing.
  4. Top with tzatziki sauce and serve with chicken skewers, if desired.
  5. Chef’s tip: Store leftover tzatziki sauce separate from salad.
collect?v=1&tid=UA 482330 7&cid=1955551e 1975 5e52 0cdb 8516071094cd&sc=start&t=pageview&dl=http%3A%2F%2Ftrack.familyfeatures SOURCE:

Author


Discover more from Daily News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Continue Reading

Trending